Correction: The analysis below appears flawed. SOHU’s market value (revenue, cash, etc) includes the portion of CYOU that SOHU owns already?
----------------------------------
I am sure that I am not the only person doing this math:
- SOHU owns 71.4% of CYOU, a cash-cow and growing business.
- CYOU’s market value is 1620M today.
- SOHU has 600M cash and no debt.
- SOHU’s market value today is 1750M.
- So SOHU’s non-gaming part of the business, i.e., advertising, search engine, and others, is valued at
- SOHU - (71.4% * CYOU + CASH) = 1750 - (0.714*1620 + 600) = -6M
In other words, SOHU’s main business (online advertising, Sogou’s search engine, the SOHU brand, etc.) is valued below ZERO as of today!
So in theory, one could buy the whole SOHU company, sell its CYOU stake and gets SOHU’s main business for free. He will probably make about 1000M instantly (if using SINA as a benchmark)!!! And if he’s good at running business, he may even spin off Sogou and make another billion!
Of course, the key assumption for the analysis above is that CYOU is indeed worth that much (1620M) and that SOHU’s other businesses won’t collapse. Note CYOU’s P/E is only 5.53(GOOGLE) or 11.02(YAHOO). It just released a new package for game TLBB and the second major game LDJ is to be released during second half of the year.
Now what if CYOU is NOT worth that much, no problem! One strategy would be to buy SOHU and short CYOU in a 1:0.714 dollar ratio. It’s equivalent to buying SOHU the Company now and sell CYOU the Company right away, both at today’s market price (and pocket the difference).
The weird thing is, if we remember what happened last year, SOHU’s price can go even lower, thanks to the madness of the market. People are so irrational they actually throw away cash, or sell $1 cash for, say ten cents!
In the meantime, analysts have been busy down-grading SOHU lately.